Widgets Magazine

The Fandom Post - Top Anime

Collapse
This is a sticky topic.
X
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • GingaDaiuchuu
    started a topic The Fandom Post - Top Anime

    The Fandom Post - Top Anime

    It's been a year since we (as AoD/Mania) have had one of these last updated. something just started a new thread over there to post your top 10 favorite anime, but it doesn't include points or a master list, plus I feel that most of that community has moved over here. Hopefully this will turn out better than the Top Video Games thread. Here is the Old List for reference. As was the case in that thread, even if you have submitted a list before, you still need to submit a new list, as this is a complete restart.

    This post is just the old Top Anime thread's first post copy/pasted with some edits to better fit this version of it, so thanks, Moe Moe Taiga. Since that was in turn made by combining some guidelines from both of the Most Wanted threads and the earlier Top 10 thread, thanks to Fudce and dunno as well. Extra special thanks to einhorn303 for providing me with the program that allows me to run this, as well as helping me understand all its workings.

    Posting a New List

    * Include a note stating that you are posting a new list.
    * List your top 10 favorite anime.
    * With every anime you list, include an Anime News Network ID number (Which can be found here. Search for your title. It's the number at the end of the URL.) I'm not aware of any cases of people's favorite anime not being on ANN, but if it's not, just replace the number with a note saying that, and I'll make sure it gets added in equally.
    * Either rank your anime from #1 to #10, or include a note stating your list is unranked.

    Updating Your List

    * Don't edit your post. Make a new one when updating your list.
    * Include a note stating that you are updating your previous list.
    * Include your previous list. You may do this in any form you choose, but the easiest way is to hit the QUOTE button on your previous list.
    * Try to avoid quoting multiple old lists in one post. If necessary when quoting your list, delete all of the quote except your previous list.

    Ranking

    * If you have a ranked list, #1 will be given 10 points, #2 will be given 9 points, and so on.
    * Titles on an unranked list will be given 5.5 points each.
    * Only the top 25 titles will be showed in the root post.
    * Titles in the root post will be displayed in this fashion:

    MovementIcon Rank. Name of Title (ANN #) - Points [# of #1 Votes]

    * Here's a legend for icons by the ranks.

    ► - NO Change
    ▲ - Moving UP into top 25
    ▲ - Moving UP
    ▼ - Moving DOWN

    Eligibility

    * The list will be open to TV series, OVAs/OADs/ONAs, Movies, Specials, and One-Offs.
    * This is the major difference between the previous thread and this one; all anime is eligible.

    Notes

    * This list will be updated around 1 time per month. It may be more or less depending on the number of lists submitted or updated in any given time period, and how much the master list will be affected by them.
    * Series with multiple seasons should be grouped in a combined entry using the ANN # of the first season. The name before the ANN # can be of the first season, a later season or seasons, both or all, or an overall series name.
    * The above rule does not include Remakes, Retellings, or series set in a different universe. (Examples: FMA and FMA: Brotherhood, Key adaptations (Toei and KyoAni), Neon Genesis Evangelion and Rebuild of Evangelion, etc.)
    * Prequels can stand alone if they don't require having seen the original. Anime that are significantly different in style from another part of their series may be separated if the general opinion is that they deserve to be because of this.
    * Any individual cases can be brought up and discussed, but as a general rule, try to use the ANN # of the first anime a person would have to see before seeing the installment in the series that may be your favorite. This is done so that a series with multiple installments only has to take up one spot on your list, and so all votes for that series will be added into one entry.
    * So even if, under the previous rules, an anime would be grouped with another anime and use an ANN # other than its own, if the general opinion is that this anime is so superior that is deserves to be recognized on its own, it can be submitted under that name and ANN #, and the results will tell if that opinion was indeed widespread enough. Technically, you could include any ANN # you want, but these guidelines are here to inform you that your vote may be lost behind all the people who may have used the ANN # of an earlier entry in the series, and that using that ANN # like them would have added to that count rather than being a lone vote.

    Top 25 Anime (Updated 12/18/2012)
    ► 01. Cowboy Bebop (13) - 94 [4]
    ► 02. Cardcaptor Sakura/Cardcaptor Sakura: The Movie/Cardcaptor Sakura Movie 2: The Sealed Card (126) - 64 [3]
    ▲ 03. Clannad/Clannad After Story (7809) - 57 [2]
    ▲ 04. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood (10216) - 50 [1]
    ▼ 05. Neon Genesis Evangelion (49) - 49 [0]
    ▲ 06. Toradora! (10050) - 46 [1]
    ► 07. Gurren Lagann (6698) - 45 [1]
    ▲ 07. Whisper of the Heart (847) - 45 [1]
    ▼ 09. Revolutionary Girl Utena (207) - 42 [0]
    ▼ 10. Princess Tutu (1267) - 40 [2]

    ▲ 11. The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya/The Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya (6430) - 37 [2]
    ▼ 12. Puella Magi Madoka Magica (12120) - 33 [0]
    ▼ 13. Rurouni Kenshin: Trust & Betrayal (210) - 30 [0]
    ▲ 14. Haibane Renmei (1871) - 29 [1]
    ▼ 15. Kiki's Delivery Service (595) - 28 [0]
    ▼ 16. Azumanga Daioh (799) - 27 [1]
    ▼ 16. Spirited Away (377) - 27 [1]
    ▲ 18. Bakemonogatari (10196) - 26 [1]
    ▼ 18. One Piece (836) - 26 [2]
    ▼ 20. Patlabor The Mobile Police (59) - 26 [0]
    ▼ 20. Urusei Yatsura (90) - 26 [0]
    ▲ 22. K-ON! (10562) - 25 [0]
    ▼ 23. FLCL (277) - 24 [1]
    ▼ 24. Sailor Moon/Sailor Moon R/Sailor Moon S/Sailor Moon SuperS/Sailor Moon Sailor Stars (363) - 24 [0]
    ▼ 25. Code Geass: Lelouch of the Rebellion (6704) - 23 [1]

    If you have any questions/comments/suggestions, post them here or PM me. Thanks for the Sticky, Hayate Kurogane!

    Everyone submit away!
    Last edited by GingaDaiuchuu; 12-18-2012, 04:00 PM.

  • BWBODDY
    replied
    There might be some bleed over, the same Title making more than one list.

    Anime Top 10
    Banner of the Stars Trilogy ( my Sentimental Favorite, it's the reason I got into Anime )
    Cowboy Bebop
    Ghost in the Shell ( entire GITS Collection )
    Gunslinger Girl
    Elfen Lied
    Serial Experiments Lain
    Heroic Age
    Bubblegum Crisis ( entire Bubbleverse Collection )
    Black Lagoon
    FLAG

    & plus ten

    Genshaft
    MORIBITO: Guardian of the Spirit
    WITCHBLADE
    The Irresponsible Captain Tylor
    Ergo Proxy
    Witch Hunter Robin
    RIN -Daughter of Mnemosyne
    GOLGO 13
    NOIR - MADLAX - EL CAZADOR De La Bruja ( the Trilogy as a whole )
    Ninja Nonsense

    Anime Movie Top 10
    Perfect Blue
    Summer Wars
    Wicked City
    Jin-Roh
    Vexille
    Steamboy
    The Sky Crawlers
    Ninja Scroll
    Sin: The Motion Picture
    Bayonetta

    Studio Ghibli Movie Top 10
    Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind
    Castle in the Sky
    Kiki?s Delivery Service
    Whisper of the Heart
    Princess Mononoke
    Spirited Away
    Howl?s Moving Castle
    The Secret World of Arrietty
    From up on Poppy Hill
    My Neighbor Totoro

    Leave a comment:


  • BlaizeV
    replied
    Re: The Fandom Post - Top Anime

    Just thought I'd do this anyway even if the list is dead

    01. Fullmetal Alchemist [2960]/Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood [10216]
    02. Eureka Seven [4797]
    03. Monster [3750]
    04. Maison Ikkoku [376]
    05. Hajime No Ippo [1139]/New Challenger [10387]/Rising [15542]
    06. Kaiji [8850]
    07. One Piece [836]
    08. Future Boy Conan [899]
    09. Blood+ [5088]
    10. Steins;Gate [11770]

    Other shows I consider 10/10 shows are

    Anohana
    Another
    Attack on Titan
    The Eccentric Family
    Flowers of Evil
    From The New World
    Gungrave
    Last Exile
    Mushishi
    Nodame Cantabile
    Psycho-Pass

    Leave a comment:


  • DiRF
    replied
    Re: The Fandom Post - Top Anime

    I never posted in this thread? WHAT?!

    New List! (I may have had a list in the old Mania AoD days, but I haven't been there in forever, damned if I'll find the list)

    1. Azumanga Daioh (799)
    2. The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya/The Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya (6430)
    3. Neon Genesis Evangelion (49)
    4. Girls und Panzer (14334)
    5. Initial D: All Stages (395)
    6. Full Metal Panic? FUMOFFU (155) (This season specifically... Didn't particularly care for the first season, and TSR was... ok)
    7. The Girl Who Leapt Through Time (6733)
    8. Karin (5949)
    9. Millennium Actress (374)
    10. Cowboy Bebop (13)

    Leave a comment:


  • Combou
    replied
    Re: The Fandom Post - Top Anime

    1 Detective Conan
    2 Kemono no Souja Erin
    3 Kimagure Orange Road
    4 Maison Ikkoku
    5 D.N.Angel
    6 Romeo's Blue Skies
    7 Skip Beat!
    8 hack//Sign
    9 Cardcaptor Sakura
    10 Blood+

    Leave a comment:


  • Basarabian
    replied
    Re: The Fandom Post - Top Anime

    I'll just list 10 without the numbers.

    Salamander OAV
    Starzinger
    Xabungle
    Rurouni Kenshin
    Gurren Lagann
    Hellsing
    Voltes V
    Blood+
    Asobot Goku (Monkey Typhoon)
    SDF Macross TV

    Leave a comment:


  • Shin Seikatsu
    replied
    Re: Damius - Top 10

    Originally posted by GingaDaiuchuu View Post
    Originally posted by Damius View Post
    Would it be possible for my list to be removed?
    I'm not updating it to add lists, so I'm not going to update it to remove one. Why would you want it removed anyway?
    It could be done when you'll update the list next time. As for the recasons, I would prefer you pm me if you want them. (i would just say for now that it has nothing to do with this thread)

    Leave a comment:


  • GingaDaiuchuu
    replied
    Re: Damius - Top 10

    Originally posted by Damius View Post
    Would it be possible for my list to be removed?
    I'm not updating it to add lists, so I'm not going to update it to remove one. Why would you want it removed anyway?

    Leave a comment:


  • Shin Seikatsu
    replied
    Re: Damius - Top 10

    Would it be possible for my list to be removed?

    Leave a comment:


  • Eka
    replied
    Re: The Fandom Post - Top Anime

    I know this is over, but I figured I'd list mine as well and just edit it if the thread is completely dead.

    1. Eureka seveN (4797)
    2. The Vision of EscaFlowne (240)
    3. Wolf's Rain (1806)
    4. Trigun (88)
    5. Space Brothers (13890)
    6. Time of EVE (7998)
    7. Redline (6456)
    8. Summer Wars (10544)
    9. Tiger & Bunny (12198)
    10. Puella Magi Madoka Magica (12120)

    Leave a comment:


  • Kastel
    replied
    Re: The Fandom Post - Top Anime

    A little girl like me should have good taste.

    1. Katanagatari
    2. Bakemonogatari
    3. Girls und Panzer
    4. Kyouran Kazoku Nikki
    5. Kyousogiga (ONA)
    6. Heartcatch Precure
    7. Kamichu!
    8. Top wo Nerae/Gunbuster
    9. Hotarubi
    10. Saki

    Kastel-kun@Ganbaranai on finding ANN IDs because this is a dead thread =w=
    Last edited by Kastel; 05-13-2013, 08:44 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • stardf29
    replied
    stardf29's Top 10 Anime Shows

    So I know the list won't be updated in the foreseeable future, but there's still no reason I can't keep a current list of my top 10 for purely informative purposes. The old list will be quoted in case the ranking does ever get updated, but again, this is more for those who are wondering what my favorite shows are.

    Originally posted by stardf29 View Post
    1. Clannad (+After Story) (7809)
    2. AnoHana (12368)
    3. Nichijou (12142)
    4. Humanity Has Declined (13787)
    5. Mahoraba ~Heartful Days~ (4631)
    6. Hidamari Sketch (6811)
    7. Bunny Drop (12398)
    8. Fruits Basket (348)
    9. Stellvia (74)
    10. Cardcaptor Sakura (126)
    1. Aria (5504)
    2. Clannad (+After Story) (7809)
    3. AnoHana (12368)
    4. Nichijou (12142)
    5. Humanity Has Declined (13787)
    6. Mahoraba ~Heartful Days~ (4631)
    7. Hidamari Sketch (6811)
    8. AKB0048 (13805)
    9. Haibane Renmei (1871)
    10. K-ON! (10562)

    Note that unless the group ranking does get updated, instead of posting new lists I will simply edit this list anytime my Top 10 changes. Consider this my official "Top 10 Anime" post on this forum.
    Last edited by stardf29; 07-21-2013, 10:40 PM. Reason: Added Haibane Renmei.

    Leave a comment:


  • GingaDaiuchuu
    replied
    Re: The Fandom Post - Top Anime

    Originally posted by 27CansOfTuna View Post
    I hope I did this right never saw this thread before.

    1 Neon Genesis Evangelion (49)
    2 Angel Beats (10885)
    3 Phi Brain: Kami no Puzzle (12271)
    4 Guilty Crown (13001)
    5 Blast of Tempest (14331)
    6 K (14732)
    7 Accel World (13857)
    8 Sacred Seven (12393)
    9 Durarara!! (10947)
    10 Mobile Suit Gundam Wing (26)
    I couldn't have possibly made it more clear that the time to submit lists was over, but yes, that would be an acceptable submission. Again, I may update it once again one day, but that likely won't be for a year or so, so it's essentially over for all intents and purposes.

    Leave a comment:


  • 27CansOfTuna
    replied
    Re: The Fandom Post - Top Anime

    I hope I did this right never saw this thread before.

    1 Neon Genesis Evangelion (49)
    2 Angel Beats (10885)
    3 Phi Brain: Kami no Puzzle (12271)
    4 Guilty Crown (13001)
    5 Blast of Tempest (14331)
    6 K (14732)
    7 Accel World (13857)
    8 Sacred Seven (12393)
    9 Durarara!! (10947)
    10 Mobile Suit Gundam Wing (26)

    Leave a comment:


  • Njr Resurrection
    replied
    Re: The Fandom Post - Top Anime

    Good to see LoGH there!

    What an epic licensing that would be if (say) Discotek or Nozomi picked that up, (even if just the TV series)!

    Leave a comment:

Widgets Magazine
Widgets Magazine

Channels

Collapse

Widgets Magazine
Widgets Magazine
Working...
X